Chicago Celebrates First American Pope in History

The election of Robert Prevost as Pope Leo XIV has ignited a wave of national pride across American social media. Following Thursday’s announcement, users enthusiastically celebrated the historic appointment of the first American pontiff, and particularly highlighted his Chicago roots.

The outpouring of excitement was swift and widespread. Prominent figures from across the political spectrum joined in the online conversation. Democratic strategist David Axelrod expressed his surprise and delight with an emphatic post, while Meghan McCain, daughter of the late Senator John McCain, shared her enthusiasm with multiple exclamation points.

Beyond political commentators, the news resonated with a broader range of online personalities. Barstool Philly quickly noted Prevost’s connection to Villanova University, and podcaster Mueller, She Wrote, simply stated the historical significance of the event. Journalist Kat Abughazaleh’s succinct “CHICAGO POPE?!” captured the sentiment of many, echoed by New York Times columnist Jamelle, who celebrated “a Chicago Guy for pope.” Even author Meg Elison injected a bit of levity, playfully referencing a potential “holy pizza wars.”

The Chicago connection proved a particularly strong theme. Barstool Chicago proudly proclaimed the Pope’s upbringing within the city, and Midwest vs. Everybody emphasized his Midwestern origins. Journalist Ed Krassenstein offered a brief profile, noting Pope Leo XIV’s centrist political leanings and progressive views on social issues.

While the initial reaction is largely celebratory, the appointment of an American Pope – and one from a major U.S. city – undoubtedly marks a significant moment for the Catholic Church and its American followers. It remains to be seen how this historic choice will shape the Church’s future, but the immediate response demonstrates a clear sense of national pride and excitement.